Showing posts with label money management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label money management. Show all posts

2011-04-20

Happy Birthday

Hello everybody,

Exactly a year ago we started with our semi automated betting bot, so today it is its first anniversary.

What an exciting year it has been. The first three days produced a loss of -1.67pts, -4.25pts and -22.80pts. I was a little disappointed then, but I stuck to it and the next two days produced a profit of 2.25pts and 55.33pts.

There have been good days and also not that good days, but right now with all the experience I got during the year those bad periods does not affect my mood anymore.

Let’s have a look at the stats of the first year:

Total PL 2,230.94pts
Total days 297
Days in Profit 176
Days in Loss 121
Max daily Profit 73.58pts
Max daily Loss -43.50pts
Avg PL per Day 7.51pts

profit

The most challenging part of the year was the bank building process. From 05/29/2010 to 08/02/2010 (60 days!) we only managed to make 7.74 pts. We checked again and again our software and luckily we could identify a bug and solve it.
This really helped, so August 2010 produced a total profit of 305.59pts.
I do not want to have another bank building process anymore. Building a decent betting bank requires a lot of discipline and patience. I think this is the most challenging part for every beginner of professional betting or trading when starting with a small bank. If you lose five quid you might think that is not that much, but percentage wise (if it is 1% of your betting bank) it can be costly. If you lose 5 quid of your bank of 500 quid's – no problem. If your bank is 5000 quid’s you will lose 50 quid’s which might be a problem. Therefore I am always thinking in points rather than in Euro.
Tracking your betting or trading results helps you to stay focused. I am lucky, because I do not have to track my results manually, it is done by the software automatically, but having a look at the graph of the betting bank on a daily basis helps a lot to stay focused.

So what to expect from the next year? I will be really pleased to produce the same profit again. No chase, no run for random numbers and goals, just making profit. It will be interesting to see how the performance will be from today until 08/02/2011, because the bug is eliminated and I am pretty sure the results for this period in 2011 will be much better than in 2010.

Another important thing I need to mention is ‘motivation’. I stay motivated by listening to certain music when the profit comes in. So when I had a really good day I always enjoy those two songs:

 

I start the day always with this one:

I think this technique comes from Neuro-linguistic programming and is called “Anchoring”. Give it a try.

That’s it for now.
I now I promised you a report about the trading seminar a few weeks ago in Manchester. You will get it, but not today ;-)

Cheers, Loocie

2009-12-30

Review and Preview

My 2nd year of trading on sports is over. Let’s have a look how I did:

Review of 2009

Tennis: 
I started well with a pleasant January profit of +€32.77 and a fantastic February profit of +€129.74, but then I totally lost my confidence. I had a couple of losses where I made some stupid mistakes. My staking was also too aggressive and I had too big liabilities during the trades. I cut my winnings and let my losses run.
Then I took some time off from trading tennis and late in the season I decided to start again with €20.00 stakes. I changed my style of trading to just focussing on laying low odds which was really an improvement. I did not track my results as I should, so I can not give an exact overview how I did. Tracking results will be an issue for 2010.

Soccer:
Did not trade that much soccer, but had a few bets and trades. I tried to use Soccer Mystic and trade soccer matches, but that will not work for me. It is too boring to watch a match and the odds closely. I think I will keep having an eye on pre match odds and if I can identify a good value (like Germany v Russia) I will put in a bet. I did not track my soccer bets, but I am in a small profit.

American Football:
I was not able to trade many matches, because my Pay TV subscription expired. I started to follow Stock Lemon’s picks. I was a little lucky, because I missed some losing bets. According to a stake of €10.00 I made +€56.66.

Formula 1:
This sport was my main income source for this year. I made +€307.08 during the year. Mainly I focussed on the fastest lap market, but I also had a look at some other markets, too. There is so much value in so many markets. I learned from my mistakes of 2008, where I could not accept a loss and put more and more into a bad position.

Horse Racing:
Three years ago I started to select some false favourites on horse racing. I only paper traded those selections and it did not pay off. So I stopped it.
This year I had a look at the excel file I created in the past with the past selections and I applied some filters. If I was more patient the stats suggested a decent profit.
At the end of March I started again paper trading my lay selections with a far more patient approach. At the end of May I started putting money on the selections with a bank of €100. I started with a maximum liability of 5% of the bank. During the last two months I raised my liability to 10% of the bank. I doubled the bank in eight months, which is a pleasant result.

Betting Bots:
I was always fascinated by having a betting bot. I started developing my first Betfair API application in June 2008. I wanted to develop a mobile Betfair application for Windows Mobile devices.
In June 2009 I started to develop a betting bot.
Currently we are running two bots for horse racing. One for backing and one for laying.
It is quite disappointing that both started really well, but now they are performing not as expected. I double checked past results and source code of both bots. There is no bug. The bots are working reliable and they do the work correctly. Only the results are quite different to the past results. 
It might be possible that in the near future both bots will run in simulation mode again.
Currently I am working on the next betting bot. I have still many ideas I want to automate. Once a bot is created it just need to run and track data in simulation mode. 2010 will be exciting!

Conclusion:

The Numbers:

Starting bank: €250.00
Current bank: €825.56 (+230.22%) 

Biggest single profit: +€79.11
Biggest single loss: –€50.47

The Staking:

Staking has been always an issue for me. I tried to adapt staking rules from other traders, but this did not work for me.
Generally, I am a fan of the KISS principle: Keep It Simple and Stupid!
That’s what I did with my style of trading this year. No complex strategy, just lay low.

Patience:

With my horse laying selections I learned that it is better to stay away, if there is no good opportunity. If you can avoid losing money, you will win more money. Forcing trades and getting in too often and too early was a main problem during the last two years.

Tracking Results:

I have not been good in tracking results, especially in tennis. That’s also a reason why I can not write down my complete stats for tennis trading.

Setting Goals:

At the start of 2009 I set myself a goal to reach a net profit of €1000.00. Did not reach this goal. I have learned this year, that it is not about chasing numbers.
It is about getting a professional approach:

  • Apply always your trading rules
  • Track your results
  • Learn from mistakes (and avoid doing them again)

Preview of 2010

I will split this section into two parts: Personal Trades and Betting Bots.

Personal Trades

In 2010 I will focus on Tennis, Formula 1, Horse Racing and American Football.

Staking:

Tennis:
I will keep it as simple as possible: I will trade with a fixed staking and I will start with a stake size of €50.00.

Formula 1:
Stake size will be €20.00 to €50.00, the same like 2009.

American Football:
Stake size will be €20.00.

Horse Racing:
Will continue with a liability of 10% of the horse racing bank.

What about setting goals?
Chasing random numbers will not work for me, so I will not set me a goal to reach a certain amount of profit.
I want to turn my trading into a more professional one, so I want to concentrate on trading behaviour (applying all my rules, patience, etc) and tracking all my results.

Betting Bots

I have several ideas for automated betting. Along with the horse racing bots I am currently working on a bot for American Sports.

The goal for 2010 is to create a least one reliable bot and to create a solid income stream from it. I think in a few month I will have a couple of bots doing their work. Maybe some of them will only run in simulation mode for a while. There is no need to rush. Sooner or later they will do their work once all the parameters are found.

Changes to the Blog

I will also apply some changes to the blog. I will outsource the horse laying selections to a newsletter tool where people can subscribe/unsubscribe to. Currently I am still looking for a comfortable piece of software.

That’s it so far.
I wish all of you a prosperous new year!

Cheers, Loocie

2008-10-05

Analysis of September 2008

Hello,

today I will do my analysis of September 2008:

Trading Tennis

number of matches I traded: 37
number of wins: 18
number of losses: 19
scratched trades: 0

number of wins > 3€: 10 
number of losses > 3€: 7

total win: +74.68
total loss: -69.96
total pl: +4.72 

average win: +4.15
average loss: -3.68
average pl: +0.13 

win rate: 49%
max win: +11.15
max loss: -13.81

diagram_september

Again not a result I am very happy with. Not because of the small win, but more because I made so many mistakes:

I did not do any research before a match. I used different stake sizes and I made stupid decisions and forced trades.

So, how to change this:

Actually, I have created a cheat sheet for trading tennis with all my rules and dos and don'ts, so I can have a look at this sheet when trading tennis.

During this month I did not use the same liability in every match and this makes it difficult to measure my trading.

Trading soccer

number of matches I traded: 15
number of wins: 9
number of losses: 6
scratched trades: 0

number of wins > 3€: 6 
number of losses > 3€: 0

total win: +27.16
total loss: -10.99
total pl: +16.17 

average win: +3.02
average loss: -1.83
average pl: +1.08 

win rate: 60%
max win: +5.39
max loss: -3.00

diagram_soccer

A good result, but not perfect. I do not mean the profit, but rather the way I traded soccer. I had some wrong trades and made some avoidable mistakes.

I know there are only two or three key events during a soccer match, so if you are not prepared and you force a trade, you can lose your money very soon.

That is the problem I have sometimes when trading tennis: I know there can be many swings and flip flops, so I am too often hoping for the next swing in my favour.

Trading Formula 1

This month I learned it the hard way what can happen, if you do not take a stop loss.

The loss during the Italian Grand Prix was too massive to recover it with other trades. I was not focused on the bigger picture, I was focused on the actual battle I had.

total loss trading Formula 1: -€46.47

Trading NFL

I traded 4 matches and scratched two of them. With only 4 matches it is not 100% reliable how I can trade this sport, so I have to wait and see next month what is it about.

total profit trading NFL: +€9.91

Trading Ice Hockey

I had only one trade and made a profit. It is also not reliable. Will see, if I can trade other matches and we have to see how it will develop.

total profit trading Ice Hockey: +€4.09

Overall there is a loss in September 2008: -€11.57.

Only one trade destroyed a possible good trading result for this month. I am happy that I was able to reduce the loss, but all in all I need to learn accepting losses.

I recognized I have a problem with a loss, if I made stupid mistakes. Even if I enter a match when there is no trading spot and I recognize it, when the trade goes against me, then I can not accept the loss. I try to correct the mistake within the same situation (mostly with over staking), but this is not possible. Actually I am still a beginner in sports trading and I am still making mistakes. I have to accept that and should not force something. How can I learn from these mistakes (taking a position when there is no trading opportunity) when I make other mistakes (over staking), which cover the underlying mistake?

To accept making mistakes I must not have fear when trading. I have fear when I use too high stakes. So my stake sizes I defined in my analysis of August 2008 are way too high.

Actually, I have not found the best money management rules for me. But it is quite ironic that I write something about money management into my dos and don'ts, but I do not follow them by myself:

"Manage your risk by trading with the right size stakes.
This is very important and depends on 2 things - the price of the selection and the size of your trading bank."

My actual stake sizes does not depend on those two things, so it is time to change that. I have worked out the following table (bankroll 119.50€):

money_management

My actual bankroll is €119.50 so I do not risk more than 20% on every trade.

Stake size is only one part of risk management. Another part is taking stop losses. I think there are different kinds of stop losses:

  • Stop loss during a trade
  • Maximum loss limit per event
  • Maximum loss limit per day

The stop loss during a trade is something you have to define before you put on a trade. This can be a price of a selection or a score during a match.

Actually, I have not a maximum limit per event or day defined, so I will do that now. This should help me to see the bigger picture and not to over stake during a match or a day.

Maximum loss limit per event: 10€ (~8% of bankroll)
Maximum loss limit per day: 25€ (~20% of bankroll)

I am not sure, if these figures are perfect, but now I have rules which should prevent me from losing more than I can accept and when I think about these figures then I can say these are amounts I can accept as a loss.

I am sure this is not my last change of stake sizes and loss limits, but now I have rules and limits, which should help me to see the bigger picture. Any comments, tips or ideas are much appreciated.

Overall stats:

September 08: -€11.57
August 08: -€7.74
July 08: +€29.10
June 08: +€25.90
May 08: +€1.36
April 08: +€25.27
March 08: +€3.08

I had also some trades during the last few days. I will update them later in the evening or tomorrow.
All the best with trading!

Cheers, Loocie

2008-09-06

Analysis of August 2008

Hello,

today I have the time to write something about my analysis of August 2008. Here is an overview of my result of August 2008:

pl_august

What an awful trading result!

Trading tennis:

number of matches I traded: 24
number of wins: 11
number of losses: 12
scratched trades: 1

number of wins > 3€: 8 
number of losses > 3€: 8

total win: +58.12
total loss: -110.30
total pl: -52.18

average win: +5.28
average loss: -9.19
average pl: -2.17

win rate: 48%
max win: +13.57
max loss: -37.79

graph

I had two trades, where I took my personal stop loss too late, so I lost more than 20€ twice. Most important factor for the bad result was impatience. Trading tennis at the Olympic Games was impossible, because I had no reliable live ticker.

The tennis circuit is also near the end of the season, so players are fatigued. That is something I have to keep in my mind for trading tennis in the next weeks.

Trading 5 set matches is also something I have problems with. Odds are moving a little different to 3 set matches.

Trading Motor Sport:

I was trading Formula 1 and MotoGP:

motor_sports

Trading the Fastest Lap market of Formula 1 races is working good. Trading MotoGP Winner market is also interesting, but I had to learn not to get involved pre race. Last weekend I got involved pre race and took my stop loss too late, so I had a loss of -€21.84.

Trading Soccer:

soccer

That's what I call discipline! Not because there is no loss, but I scratched so many matches. Even if there would be some small losses it would be a great result. I took all stop losses and closed the trades as soon as possible. I also selected the matches carefully. Every weekend we find many matches in many football leagues, so I can watch many matches and enter a market if there is a good opportunity.

The key is to identify matches with good opportunities. It is not good to watch a game and force a trade during this game, so you can not say "I trade the Chelsea vs Manu match tonight." It is similar to tennis trading. I watch matches live or via live ticker and if I can identify a good trading opportunity, than I enter the market.

Trading other sports:

During August 2008 I had a look at other sports to trade on. Handball and Basketball can offer also good opportunities. NBA is starting in October, I think, so I will have a look. Also NFL has started and I will trade some matches.

Overview:

Tennis: -52.18
Motor Sports: +14.34
Soccer: +26.65
Others: +3.45

total loss this month: -€7.74

What is the conclusion of this month?

First of all: Discipline, discipline and discipline! That is really a serious issue. I have to handle this trading as a business. If you make profit, you are not 'winning'. 'Winning' is something I associate with lottery or something else. I think I should not speak or write about wins and losses, but more about successful and unsuccessful trades. Every trade should be handled as an investment and if this investment does not move in your predicted direction, stop it and minimize your risk and live with this unsuccessful trade.

The next issue is money management. I did not write about it in the past, because I have not found a good money management strategy for me yet.

Actually I have the rule not to lose more than 20€ per trade. But this rule is not the best. If I back a player at 1.5 with 10€, I can let this trade run and lose my whole stake without breaking the rule, but afterwards I can not call this trade as a good trade, because I lost my whole stake. Also if my initial stake is too high, I have to take a possible stop loss very quickly, because my edge of a maximum loss of 20€ can be reached very quickly.

At the moment my stake size depends on self confidence and the trading opportunity I identify. If I am exactly, it depends on my feeling about my self confidence.

So what is possible:

  1. Flat stake - I have to use the same amount of money for my stake. That means I back and lay with the same amount. Depending on the odds my risk can be very low (f.e. if I lay at 1.1) or it can be very high (f.e. if I lay at 4).
  2. Flat liability - I have to calculate my stake size depending on the odds to risk the same amount of money each trade.
  3. Variable stake size - Sounds easy, just trade with the ideal amount of money.

I think there are more possibilities about staking. You also can adjust these three staking methods, f.e. you are using flat stakes, but the stake size depends on your bank, so maybe you say you are risking 20% of your bank on each trade.

The most important requirement for me is, the money management strategy should be simple. I do not want to calculate a complex formula to get my stake size, because very often you need to react very quickly.

I have read also articles and blog entries from other web sites about staking:

Mark Iverson - How Do You Like Your Stake?
He uses a staking strategy depending on his bankroll and the available odds:

1.01 - 1.50 = 40%
1.50 - 2.00 = 27%
2.00 - 3.00 = 13%
3.00 - 4.00 = 8%
4.00 - 5.00 = 6%
5.00 - 6.00 = 4%

The question is, how he uses this table? Only for backing or only for laying? I will explain what I mean:

Firstly, let me say I am calculating my explanation with a bank of €100, so it is easy to calculate stake size. I also only write about markets with only two outcomes.

If you lay a player or team @1.2, what is you stake and your risk? If you lay with a stake of 40% of you bank, you lay 40€@1.2, that means your risk is €8.

Remember, you want to lay a player or a team, that means, you think this player or team will not win, so you can also back the event, that the player or team will not win, so your back odds are 6. Now your stake size is 4€ according to the table above and your risk is 4€, 50% of the risk, if you lay the player or team.

Actually he has now a higher bankroll and he changed the percentage of the stakes, but the principle is the same. I will ask him and update this blog entry later.

The Betfair Trader - Trading and money management

He uses blocks of 250. That means he backs and lays with 250 and his risk is 250 if he back a selection and his risk is lower than 250 if he lays a selection because he always trades the favourite and laying the favourite seems to mean laying below odds of 2.0. He also changed this blocks of money depending on his trading bank. The most important thing is he defined an maximum amount of money he can afford to lose. When using blocks of 500 he takes a stop loss at -250, so his maximum loss should be -250.

Money management has also to do with taking stop losses, so I think it should be called risk management.

I have an actual bankroll of €96.22 and I will treat this as €100. So here is the maximum liability of every sport I trade on:

Tennis: €50
Soccer: €20
Formula 1: €50
MotoGP: €10
NFL: €10
Other Sports: €10

Depending on the liability I will set a maximum loss of 50% of the liability:

Sport Max. Liability Stop Loss at
Tennis 50 -25
Soccer 20 -10
Formula 1 50 -25
MotoGP 10 -5
NFL 10 -5
Other Sports 10 -5


This month (September 2009) I have had some trades, but from now on, I will follow this risk management rules and I am really interested how it works.

Much written so far, so it is time to come to an end for this blog entry. This weekend is another Formula 1 weekend, so I will trade the Fastest Lap market. Later this day we have Tennis and Soccer, but I am not sure, if I am able to trade today.

All the best for trading!

Cheers, Loocie